Ashley Fox of The Philadelphia Enquirer checks in and says, among other things, that this should be the last season that Donovan McNabb is the quarterback of the Eagles. That being said, she argues that he deserves a graceful exit. From her piece…
After 10 years in this town with this franchise, that’s only fair to McNabb. When it is time, and it certainly appears as if that time is just about here, McNabb deserves a graceful exit.
During an atypically introspective day-after news conference yesterday following the Eagles’ stunning 13-13 tie with the Cincinnati Bengals, Reid publicly backed his starting quarterback. He said there was no situation right now in which he would consider getting a look at Kolb in a game.
“No,” Reid said flatly, “that’s not what I’m doing right now. Donovan will continue to be the quarterback. Donovan, for every throw that he didn’t make there, he’ll get himself back. I know that he has already talked to you guys after the game and put the blame on his back, which quarterbacks do. He’ll continue to fire and get whatever is wrong straightened out and get it right.”
Sure, there is mounting evidence that McNabb is on the downward slope of his career. The Eagles’ offense has been erratic this season, and McNabb has been a brutally slow starter these last four weeks and hasn’t been able to lead the Eagles back from behind once all season.
His passes at times have sailed way above the heads of his receivers, and at other times have landed awkwardly at the receivers’ feet or out of their reach.
Despite saying he’s finally 100 percent healthy after a knee injury prematurely ended his 2006 season, McNabb hasn’t tucked the football and run often enough when plays have broken down. He hasn’t been able to make something out of nothing, that unique gift that made McNabb so special earlier in his career.
And then there was the gaffe to beat all gaffes on Sunday. Every time I hear the clip, it sounds more absurd that McNabb didn’t know that regular-season games that are still tied after 15 minutes of overtime end in a tie.
You can read the rest of the piece, here.